User Message: Dear House of Representative Doyle Heffley; ,

I would like to thank you for speaking out on Panther Valley raising taxes due to the homestead exemption. They stated the same thing last year adding that the money for the homestead is taken from their budget. I wrote a letter to the editor saying that they wee receiving 1.1 million dollars and they couldn’t legally raise taxes due to the Homestead money.

But you said in your letter we need to have an honest conversation about school funding. I wrote letters to the Times News, the Attorney General, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and you about how bringing Portnoff in to collect delinquent taxes was making people lose their homes. No one replied. .

While I was researching this collection scheme I found out the school district assigns (sells) the liens to Public Asset Management (Luzerne County Redevelopment Authority) for 60-80 cents on the dollar. The homeowner pays 3-4 times the original amount to keep their home. None of this extra money goes to the school district, the poor are subsidizing the rich.

These liens are paid and the interest keeps going being collected by Portnoff along with the attorney fees and costs. PAM receives a percent, even though they file as a non profit, Municipal Revenue Service gets a percent for over seeing this process.. FNCB (US Bancorp) is the assignee of PAM and receive interest. Eckert, Seamons, Cherling, and Merlot Law issues bonds for the government debt, Stifel Niclaus is the bond underwriters, They both receive fees. PFM Financial Advisors and Pfm Distributors advise the district and receive percent's of the profits.

Of course Portnoff’s fees are the highest, 3 letters from Portnoff costs over 700 dollars before a sale is even scheduled. Taking it a step further, PLGIT the Pennsylvania pension pool of the local governments buy these bonds and pay sponsorship fees to the PA Association of Boroughs, the PA County Commissioners, the PA Association of Township Supervisors, the PA Municipal Authorities, Pa association of School directors and The Pa Municipal League.

This affects the most vulnerable in the communities. The poor and the elderly are more likely to have a home owned out-right and this steals the equity from the home owners and creates communities of blight and rental properties. On paper this resembles a Ponzi scheme and putting people out of their homes to be part of someone’s portfolio is investing in distress on a level they should be ashamed of. Thank you for your time

I like to rob banks. It’s profitable, and it doesn’t keep me from having the time to do the things I like to do. Unfortunately, the law says I can’t steal money from banks and the police are closing in on me. I really don’t want to go to jail and I especially don’t want to have to pay the money back. So I’m going to Harrisburg and I’m going to give the lawmakers money to change the law to make bank robbery legal. And since I broke the law in the past, I’ll make the new law retroactive back to when I first started robbing banks.

Sounds ridiculous? Not if you’re Michelle Portnoff, the delinquent tax collector of many municipalities in Pennsylvania. Portnoff Law started collecting delinquent taxes in the early 90’s and their outrageous fees landed them in a class action lawsuit. It was ruled that they were collecting taxes illegally and were required to pay 5 million dollars to the people affected. In 2003, Senator Jane Orie sponsored a bill making their actions legal and made it retroactive back to 1996. Portnoff didn’t pay a dime. A few years later, Ms. Orie went to prison for corruption, even submitting fraudulent documents in her own trial.

Prior to this amendment, in 1996 Alan Portnoff drafted and lobbied for legislation to add attorney fees to a municipal claims/lien. The Senate majority leader was “consulting” for a similar for-profit collector, being paid more than his government salary while pushing legislation through that benefitted these companies. He also went to jail and returned as a lobbyist.

Michelle Portnoff’s campaign contributions include five more lawmakers caught up in corruption who went to jail. She also financially supported committee members who backed bills that benefitted her firm, judges who ruled on cases in litigation, and made generous donations to PAC committees and municipal associations — enabling “quiet lobbying.”

Today, Portnoff has a bullet-proof collection scheme from three decades of small amendments to a law enacted in 1901 for municipal claims. Does the corruption stop there? Local solicitors brought collectors to the table. The county prothonotary refused to file documents when I tried pushing back on this matter; some filings even went missing. Are there incentives not seen? Right-to-Know requests receive silence from the school district even after paying Portnoff $10,000 for the legal work in the sale of tax liens.

Lansford council choosing Portnoff to fund keeping the streets nice only to put residents out to live on them is considerate; but I hope they realize they only enabled Portnoff to collect attorney fees twice for one property. They receive zero of the extra money charged. This only creates more blight, brings everyone’s property value down, and increases rental properties’ ability to raise rent. Does Lansford even receive income tax from landlords?

I’m convinced the government agencies at play are either in on the corruption or not smart enough to understand they’re being played for profit. The Real Estate Tax Sale Law governs the collection of delinquent taxes and created the Tax Claim Bureau with the sole purpose to collect delinquent taxes. This wasn’t an open position Portnoff applied for, and the authority of the council to bring in a private, for-profit debt collector questions the delegation of government’s sovereign power. It exists because the state exists — you can’t give that away.

Also, the very familiar yet simplistic narrative of blaming some residents for being the reason to increase fees is really playing like a broken record — the anthem of Lansford lately. The more complex version of poor planning, hidden agendas, and financial ignorance is more plausible. I’ll never feel guilty when I pay a bill late, especially after paying interest, administrative fees, and sometimes a hefty turn-on fee.

Local government and school districts operate like classic pyramid schemes, where growth is desperate to sustain long-term liabilities of the previous elected government. The need to issue more debt for current payments to create the illusion of wealth isn’t realistic — and we’re feeling the effects of decades of this process. We need sustainable revenue and a transparent government.

I’m writing this letter in response to the Panther Valley School Board voting to raise the millage rate for the 2024-25 year. This area is a depressed, poverty stricken district. The median income is ranked 467 out of 499 school districts in Pennsylvania. Yet were taxed 10th highest. Inflation was implied as a reason they need extra tax revenue. The economy affects everyone and it’s hard to feel sympathy for a district that wants to take money away from our basic needs while planning a new school construction project. Another reason stated was that The Homestead Act took money away from the budget. The Taxpayer Relief Act provides school districts the means to lower property taxes to homeowners, via the funding provided by gaming revenue. The Dept of Education's website states 1,118,722.82 is allocated to Panther Valley for the upcoming school year. Also the taxation manual states, “Local governments implementing homestead exclusions may not increase the millage rate on real estate to offset the revenue lost by the reduction in the tax base.” PVSD hasn’t demonstrated great financial practices in the past and it seems that could be part of the problem. Panther Valley brought in a predatory law firm in 2000 to collect delinquent taxes. This triples the original tax bill allowing them to attach fees and costs to the liens placed on the homes. Panther Valley doesn’t receive any of the extra money and has no benefit to the district. In my opinion, this has created a community of blight and rental properties. Putting people out of their homes for a 500 dollar tax bill that was inflated to 3000 from excessive fees while out of state property companies have been buying up the homes and not maintaining the properties. Now they’re selling the liens to Public Asset Management, A non profit LLC company. (Luzerne County Redevelopment Company) Also using PFM Financial Advisors that oversees the loans and Municipal Revenue Service issues bonds. Stifel Nicolaus as an underwriter, with Eckert, Seamons, Cherin and Mellot and their legal team issuing general obligation bonds. (Gov’t tax exempt) By investing in distress they sell the liens for approximately 60 cents on the dollar and the loan, interest and fees are paid by the delinquent homeowners over a period of 2-3 years. A big investor in this process is PLGIT. (Pennsylvania’s local government investment trust) Local governments invest money into the trust and draw from the funds as needed. This is the trust that buys the liens. Technically the local government bought the liens it sold and is paying multiple agencies to let them profit on the interest and fees paid in by the poor and elderly. On paper this resembles a Ponzi scheme. But this is my own research, and it has to be. I submitted a right to know request in September 2023 and I’m still waiting for answers. The lack of transparency in this district is concerning. Even the website has no recent financial statements, rarely posts agendas or minutes from meetings. They won’t provide proof of ordinances or resolutions issued for these practices because they believe they’re not required to have them. Who do you direct concerns to? This trust pays sponsorship fees to the PA County Commissioners, PA Municipal Authorities, PA Municipal League, PA Association of Boroughs, PA Association of Township Commissioners, and PA Association of Township Supervisors. By creating debt to finance the present they are creating the illusion of wealth. Agreeing to allocate future revenue to that debt makes economic growth as a desperation, not as a credible strategy for success. Local tax enforcement by third party debt collectors and hedge funds exploit the hardships in communities, and extract their wealth and property. Its chief victims are both the homeowners whose tax liens are purchased and those in the surrounding neighborhoods who suffer collateral damage. As a homeowner (inevitably temporary homeowner) approaching retirement age, I sometimes reminisce to the quote I learned in middle school, “A government Of the People, By the People, For the People.” Seems like a moral standard that forms and maintains communities, but I didn’t attend Panther Valley